Photo Source: The Friday Times
National Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS)
Indian Institute of Science Campus, Bangalore
For any further information or to subscribe to GP alerts send an email to subachandran@nias.res.in
Pakistan Reader
Pakistani media’s response to the Justice Saqib Nisar audio leak| Major takeaways
Ankit Singh
|
The sense ranges from feebleness of the media to frustration about misaligned coverages of issues
On 21 November, Ahmad Noorani, an investigative journalist associated with ‘FactFocus’ shared a story containing purported recording of a call conversation between a judge of accountability court and the then Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Justice Saqib Nisar. The former CJP was perceived to be guiding the National Accountability Board (NAB) judge in making sure that both father (Nawaz Sharif) and daughter (Maryam Nawaz) were punished due to dynamic requirement of institutions. The media went abuzz with back-to-back revelations from affidavit submission by Justice Imam to overturning the judgment of NAB against Maryam Nawaz by Islamabad High Court in recent weeks.
Media’s response in editorials
The editorial by Arifa Noor in Dawn, dated 30 November contrasted the stand of the opposing sides upon the revelation, treatment meted out to Sharifs versus attack on the state institutions (Idaare) by PML(N). While Ms. Noor’s stand was that the wiffle waffle of politics subsided the real issues as always. She goes on state that the judiciary is in partial amnesia vis a vis establishment. The fact that judiciary in Pakistan has had some embarrassing judgment to its log confirms the trend and Ms. Noor concludes with pity situation of the media among the institutions which can only hold forth the evidence and demand for accountability while other institutions would keep crossing the red lines to suit their hierarchy and influence.
Another editorial by Umer Farooq in The Friday Times (TFT), dated 26 November, provided more of a pragmatic perspective. Mr. Farooq wondered if PML(N) had located an internal resource person in the establishment to help them access the call recordings. The context he presented was sort of a crises undergoing in Pakistan whereby the crises has cushioned the PML(N) and circles in establishment. Mr. Farooq goes on to state that various political forces gathering to bring back the previous democratic regimes over the current hybrid dispensation. He acknowledges the convenience with which democratic political parties adjust to the scenarios, and do opportunistic politics while ignoring the ugly truth of democratic governance.
In the editorial by Ghazi Salahuddin dated 28 November for The News International, there is pondering over the judicial nexus with the establishment. The title ‘voices in the dark’ says it all, through which the judiciary is actually equally responsible for coercion and fear prevailing in the society. Mr. Salahuddin also introspects on the judgments of the past and takes example of Nusrat Bhutto to the case of Zafar Ali Shah case and makes a case for the misconduct by the judiciary when most criticality was expected of them. He maintains that judiciary has also enabled erosion of public trust in the state and perhaps that ceding of the space has sprouted many other self-proclaimed quasi-judicia-religious groups which are also making the political room more congested.
An earlier editorial by Farhatullah Babar in TFT almost a year back tried to analyse the executive interference in the domain of judiciary. Mr. Babar was of the opinion that the judiciary had undermined the importance other democratic institutions (legislature) and Justice Saqib Nisar fits well in the pattern, even with an enthusiastic approach to human rights and the building of dams the CJP had distinct characteristics of a loose canon like the many political leader in current government. Mr. Babar suggests that Saqib Nisar at least need to start with self-dignity and should choose to stay silent while many more revelations were bound to be released by the PML(N). The PML(N) has not taken the evidences to the any judicial body and has rather chosen the sensational way like press conference or social media to confirm their saga of hard luck of being wronged by the establishment.
The way forward
The PML(N) and all other political parties has to bow down to the mood and psyche of the Pakistani society and rather than masala-fying the unjustice, there is greater need to consolidate the support base instead of relying on establishment to bring PML(N) back to the fore. Judiciary for its part is already enmeshed with establishment and there may be an initiative to decouple the two so that the democratic yet not so democratic transitions are effective in terms of promises and governance and not the utopian promises every time a political party makes.
The judiciary also need to create a space in facilitating space for ultra-radicals to streamline their judicial enquiries in conformation to the constitution of Pakistan.
With regards to establishment, the voices will remain in dark and judiciary for its part need to introspect to maintain balance between autonomy and influence as both autonomy and influence are seemingly becoming opposite polars. Without judiciary remaining relevant, the Pakistani society will remain like a boiling pot waiting for its threshold destiny.
References
Arifa Noor, “Neros and the fiddles,” Dawn, 30 November 2021
Umer Farooq, “Does PML-N Have A Mole In The System?,” The Friday Times, 26 November 2021
Ghazi Salahuddin, “Voices in the dark,” The News International, 28 November 2021
Farhatullah Babar, “Saqib in the spotlight,” The Friday Times, 4 December 2020
*Note: The note was first published in http://www.pakistanreader.org/
Bookmark |
Dhriti Mukherjee
Lawyers’ protests in Lahore: Two Reasons Why
Rohini Reenum
Protests in Pakistan Occupied Kashmir: What and Why?
Dhriti Mukherjee
9 May Violence: One Event, Different Actors, Multiple Outlooks
D Suba Chandran
The Fog of 9 May: One year after the anti-Establishment violence
Rohini Reenum
Pakistan and Wheat: From a Crisis to a Scandal
D Suba Chandran
Karachi: Seven Shades of Violence
Rohini Reenum
Recurrent floods in Pakistan: What and Why
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan's Position on the War in Gaza
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan's narrow tax base: Failures so far, challenges ahead
Dhriti Mukherjee
Profile: Street Crimes in Karachi
PR Team
The Snow Leopards of Pakistan
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan grapples with soaring electricity bills and free riders
Shamini Velayutham
Pakistan: Recent spike in Polio cases
Dhriti Mukherjee
Pakistan’s power predicament: Soaring bills and public discontent
Ankit Singh
Pakistan’s Economy: Three questions
Sneha Surendran
From Cargo to Canvas: The vibrant world of Pakistani Truck Art
D. Suba Chandran
Que Sara Sara: Pakistan, Two Months After 09 May
Sneha Surendran
Pakistan’s e-Sport Industry: A Profile
Bhoomika Sesharaj
PR Explains: Pakistan’s power outage
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Pakistan’s Blue Helmets: A long-standing contribution
D Suba Chandran
Karachi: The race and new alignments for the Mayor
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Pakistan, US and Russia: Putin Online, Biden Offline
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Deepening Pakistan-Russia ties
D. Suba Chandran
Justice Ayesha: Breaking the Legal Ceiling
Ankit Singh
Pakistan's Judiciary in 2021
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Same Page Story: Civil-Military Relations in 2021
D. Suba Chandran
Pakistan's Foreign Policy in 2021
Ankit Singh
Pakistan’s economy in 2021: Major highlights
Ankit Singh
Pakistan and the Asian Development Bank
Apoorva Sudhakar
The PDM is back, again
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Qureshi’s visit to Brussels: Three takeaways
Apoorva Sudhakar
Protests in Gwadar: Four major highlights
Ankit Singh
Mini budget, IMF and a contemporary puzzle.
Ankit Singh
Pappu Sain bids adieu to the world
Apoorva Sudhakar
Smog, pollution and more: Deteriorating air quality in Pakistan
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
PTI’s secret dealing with the TTP and TLP
D. Suba Chandran
PTI’s TLP flip-flop and a secret deal
Apoorva Sudhakar
The increasing curbs on digital media freedom in Pakistan
D. Suba Chandran
TLP: The government caves in again
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
TLP is back again
Apoorva Sudhakar | Project Associate, School of Conflict and Security Studies, NIAS
Pakistan’s transgender community: The long road ahead
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Since January 2021: Why the US President has not called Pakistan’s Prime Minister so far?
Apoorva Sudhakar
No honour in honour killing
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
The Military Reshuffle: A strategic or routine decision?
D. Suba Chandran
Dr AQ Khan: Between a national hero and a nuclear proliferator
Apoorva Sudhakar
Rising child abuse in Pakistan: Five reasons why
Abigail Miriam Fernandez
Hazara Persecution in Pakistan: No end in sight
D. Suba Chandran
Protests in Gwadar: Who and Why
Juan Mary Joseph
Attacks on Chinese Investments in Pakistan: Who, Where And Why?
Apoorva Sudhakar